Bonefish fishing: which flies to use for success?

Choosing the right fly for each situation is very important for catching bonefish © Enjoy Fishing / Jean-Baptiste Vidal

Bonefish are one of the most common fly-fished species in exotic destinations. Feeding on a variety of prey, you need to know how to vary your flies to catch them regularly according to their diet, habits and destination. Here are a few essential patterns and tips for fishing bonefish around the world.

Imitation shrimp

These are the flies most often used to search for this species. Bonefish often feed on shrimp, which they find in all the habitats where they come to feed. However, they come in different sizes and colors depending on the biotope. So you need to choose the right models for each spot.

They are often tan in color, which works well on light sandy or sandy-silty bottoms near mangroves.

The olive color is best used when fishing on darker bottoms such as turtle grass, which is very rich in food, but also on flats with alternating light and darker substrates for contrast.

The pink and orange colors are also very effective, especially on aggressive, less-fished and less wary fish.

The best-known and most widely used models are crazy charlie, gotcha, verveka shrimp, spawning shrimp,...

Il est important d'avoir un large choix de crevettes mais aussi de lestage pour s'adapter aux profondeurs de pêche et du comportement des bonefish
It's important to have a wide choice of shrimp but also ballast to adapt to fishing depths and bonefish behaviour.

Weighting shrimp

Shrimp weighting is very important, depending on the fishing grounds.

You'll need different fly models, of course, but also different weights for each model!

The heaviest weights are made with lead sinkers or diabolo eyes attached near the eyelet or at the rear of the fly, but a chain sinker is often used to provide a lighter weight. Models without eyes or weights are also indispensable.

Most of the time, bonefish are caught in shallow water, between the knee and the ankle. In this case, flies should be lightly weighted, if at all.

Lavado chain weights are therefore often the most versatile. But there are still different sizes of chain, and you'll need to adapt it to each spot height.

In very shallow waters, and especially when bonefish are tailing, i.e. feeding by digging into the bottom with part of their tail out of the water, it's very often necessary to fish with unweighted flies, which are more discreet and more effective in these shallow depths.

Ce bonefish en tailing aura été pris grâce à une petite crevette olive non lestée montée sur place par l'auteur
This tailing bonefish was caught with a small unweighted olive shrimp mounted on site by the author.

If you're fishing a deep area, i.e. with more than 50 cm of water, or even more, which is rare but can happen, heavier-weighted flies should be used to get your fly to the bottom quickly, as bonefish feed mainly near the substrate.

So, you have to be careful with the weight of your fly because, if the fly is too heavy, it can :

  • Scare fish into poses and presentation.
  • Scrape the bottom, not swim like a shrimp in short bursts.
  • Move into the substrate and disappear from view of the fish.

On the other hand, a fly that is too light and less often close to the bottom may be rejected by more selective or less active fish.

Les imitations de petits crabes sont très efficaces mais souvent peu employés pour le bonefish!
Small crab imitations are very effective, but often not used for bonefish!

The little crabs

Bonefish love to eat crabs. That's why you need to have some in your box. Smaller sizes are often used than for permit, mostly in sizes 4 and 6, but a nice bonefish can take a crab mounted on a size 2.

Once again, it's important to match the color of the background so that it looks natural. They are often light, but sometimes olive.

Unlike the shrimp, the crab cannot intercept fast-moving bonefish. A shrimp will be much more useful and practical in this situation, but when bonefish are actively feeding and moving slowly, an imitation crab is very effective and can make all the difference.

Ici une sélection de l'auteur pour les bonefish de Los Roques. On notera le clouser minnow et le gummy à gauche sur la photo qui sont les plus utilisés sur ces bonefish qui se nourrissent souvent de petits poissons
Here is the author's selection for Los Roques bonefish. Note the clouser minnow and gummy on the left in the photo, which are the most commonly used on these bonefish, which often feed on small fish.

Small fish imitations

In certain situations, bonefish can take small fish imitations, as they are opportunists. Small minnow clousers work very well in this case.

In Los Roques, Venezuela, bonefish have developed the particularity of feeding mainly on small sardines and other small fish, as they swarm on this very special archipelago. The clouser minnow, but especially the gummy, are the flies most often used to imitate the forage fish.

Bonefish, like other predators (such as jacks), come to hunt them and catch them in between!

Le choix de la mouche, de sont lestage et de l'animation de la mouche influence beaucoup dans la réussite de la pêche au bonefish
The choice of fly, its weighting and the animation of the fly, has a major influence on the success of bonefish fishing.

Presentation and animation

Fly animation is also an important factor in success or failure, because depending on the behavior of the fish, you'll need to adapt your fly retrieve.

The more they are in a group or aggressive, the faster you need to bring your fly back, but you still need to take breaks to get the fly close to the bottom. This is often where the bite comes in.

Animations are often carried out with 30 cm shots to longer, slower shots of one metre.

The advantage of shrimp is that they can be thrown well ahead of the fish to intercept the bonefish and trigger one of the fish.

A crab should be animated more gently by long pulls or small animations on the bottom, or just placed on the fish's path.

More articles on the theme